该研究利用立体显微 X 光定位系统,将数百个电生理记录位点配准到清醒猕猴功能磁共振成像(fMRI)所定义的中央面孔补丁(middle face patch, MFP)的高分辨率解剖像上,在毫米与亚毫米尺度上测量了该面孔区的大小、纯度(purity,即面孔偏好位点比例)及其空间分布特征。结果支持大范围的功能聚集(补丁直径约 6 mm,中心面孔偏好位点比例最高达 93%),但不支持均一模块假说:面孔选择性在补丁内部及邻近位点之间存在明显差异,整体呈现从中心向外单调衰减的梯度,强面孔选择性位点在补丁内出现的概率约为补丁外的 40 倍。
研究背景
fMRI 能够在猕猴下颞叶定位出稳定的面孔补丁,但补丁内部是否主要由面孔特异性神经元构成仍存争议。领域特异性观点认为存在功能高度纯化且集中的特化区,而分布式表征观点则推测面孔与其他物体表征细胞广泛混合。既往电生理研究所估计的纯度差异较大(从约 40% 到接近 100% 不等),既可能反映真实的解剖变异,也可能是记录位点落在补丁中心或边缘的位置偏差所致。若无法精确建立电生理位点与 fMRI 补丁的空间对应关系,所得纯度估计便难以对上述假说进行区分。
空间定位误差是该研究的核心技术挑战。电极从背侧向深层腹侧的 MFP 进针,长距离穿刺容易将细微的角度偏差放大为显著的横向位移,脑组织受压形变也会改变实际记录深度。为了准确量化纯度,需要将记录点投射至高分辨率皮层表面,并同时评估补丁边界、选择性空间剖面以及微尺度下的邻近位点差异。即便中心纯度很高,若选择性自中心向外平滑衰减,或同一电极相距几百微米的位点表现出真实异质性,便不能简单将其描述为均一模块。
Aparicio 等结合立体显微 X 光测量与高分辨率解剖 MRI 配准,在两只清醒猕猴的 MFP 及其邻近皮层系统采集多单元与单单元电生理信号。研究比较了盒车(boxcar)模型与二维高斯模型对补丁范围的估计,采用 d' 与面孔选择性指数(FSI)两种指标计算纯度,并检验相距 500 μm 以内的位点选择性差异是否超出重复测量和刺激抽样噪声。研究旨在探讨:MFP 的空间尺度与几何形态、面孔选择性是否随离中心距离呈梯度衰减、微尺度相邻位点是否共享相同偏好,以及极端面孔选择性在补丁内外的分布特征。结果表明该区域存在中心高度富集且向外渐进衰减的梯度,同时内部存在无法被低频宏观模型完全解释的精细变异。
研究思路
研究设计通过硬件系统控制电生理记录的空间定位误差:首先利用清醒猕猴的 MION 增强 fMRI 定位 MFP;再利用定制的立体显微聚焦 X 光成像系统测定电极尖端在颅骨坐标系下的三维坐标(定位精度约 100 μm);经过线性与非线性配准(FLIRT/FNIRT),将位点映射至基于高分辨率(500 μm)结构像重建的皮层中层表面网格,并展开为近似等距的二维皮层展开图。在该连续空间表征上,分析按三个层次展开:其一,采用单试次信噪比 d' 与常规 FSI 两种指标互检位点的面孔偏好;其二,采用盒车模型、各向同性高斯及各向异性高斯模型拟合二维选择性分布,测定补丁中心、边界尺度与衰减半径;其三,分析同一电极穿刺路径上相距 ≤500 μm 的位点对,与重测噪声及图像抽样置换噪声对比,检验微尺度异质性是否源于真实的神经反应差异。
方法
实验对象为两只恒河猴(Macaca mulatta):M1(雄性,约 9 kg)与 M2(雌性,约 5 kg),均在同一实验平台下先后接受 MION 增强 fMRI 扫描与电生理记录。刺激材料包括去背景且匹配平均亮度的陌生猕猴面孔及日常物体图像;fMRI 定位采用面孔与物体的区组对比(15 张面孔对比 15 张物体;M2 电生理阶段采用其中各 10 张的子集),仅纳入对完整图像反应显著高于打乱图像的体素。清醒 fMRI 在两只动物的上颞沟(STS)下岸凸面均稳定检出后、中、前三个面孔选择性补丁;其中 MFP 位于颞下回(ITG)冠部,前后跨度约 5 mm。电生理记录采用玻璃包被钨丝微电极,沿 STS 下岸及 ITG 凸面按 200–500 μm 间隔逐点推进;采用快速序列视觉呈现(RSVP)范式(M1:每试次 7–10 张,呈现 200 ms、间隔 100 ms,每图重复 12 次;M2:12–15 张,呈现 100 ms、间隔 100 ms,每图重复 3–5 次),注视窗口限制在 2°–3°。
多单元活动(MUA)响应提取刺激呈现后 60–160 ms 的平均放电率(扣除 0–50 ms 基线放电);位点面孔偏好计算 d' = (μfaces − μobjects)/√((σ²faces + σ²objects)/2) 与 FSI = (μf − μo)/(μf + μo);两指标均表现出较高的折半信度(d' 折半相关系数 M1 r = 0.98,M2 r = 0.92)。记录位点投影到中层皮层表面网格,剔除法向位移超过 1250 μm 的位点(M1 剔除约 14%,M2 剔除约 25%),最终在以 fMRI MFP 中心为基准、测地半径 7 mm 的二维展开皮层上纳入分析(M1 包含 425 个多单元位点,M2 包含 565 个)。采用最小二乘法拟合二维空间模型,参数标准误通过 bootstrap 计算;纯度定义为达到选择性阈值的位点占该区域总采样位点的比例;按盒车拟合半径划分补丁内(in,1 倍半径内)、邻近区(near,1–2 倍半径)与外周背景区(far,2 倍半径以外)。M2 经 spike sorting 提取出 288 个单单元(SUA)作为多单元结果的对照;并按皮层深浅(距软膜或白质边界 500 μm)分别拟合以评估层间差异。
主要结果
- fMRI 定位与微电极采样的一致性:两只猕猴的 fMRI 均在 STS 下岸凸面检出稳定的 MFP,主要分布于 ITG 冠部(图 1);微电极记录在中央下颞区沿 ITG 检出对应的面孔偏好位点聚集区(pMFP,图 3)。聚集区内包含连续的面孔偏好位点(正 d'),同时分布有部分物体偏好位点(负 d')及过渡位点;折半信度检验(r = 0.98 与 0.92)排除了测量噪声对局部异质性的解释。
- 补丁尺度约为 6 mm,低频空间模型解释约三分之一方差:盒车模型拟合的直径在 M1 为 5.96 mm,M2 为 6.50 mm;各向同性高斯模型的半高全宽(FWHM)分别为 5.70 mm 与 7.10 mm;各向异性高斯模型长短轴 FWHM 分别为 4.45×2.55 mm 与 4.10×2.20 mm(图 4)。各模型确定的中心位点高度吻合(图 5);但三种模型的空间解释方差均约为 r² ≈ 0.30(M2 各向异性模型为 0.33),一维径向剖面显示实测数据相对宏观模型存在系统性高频离散,表明毫米尺度平滑梯度之下存在精细空间亚结构。
- 微尺度邻近位点存在真实的神经选择性差异:在单次电极穿刺中相距 ≤500 μm 的相邻位点对,面孔选择性的平均绝对差值达到 d' 1.04(M1)与 0.75(M2)(图 6);经重复测量置换与图像抽样估计的期望方差显著小于实测差值,证实补丁内部的选择性波动来自局部神经群体的功能异质性,而非实验测量噪声。
- 面孔选择性纯度呈现径向梯度衰减:以 d' ≥ 0.65 或 FSI ≥ 0.33(对应面孔反应至少两倍于物体反应;图 7)为选择性阈值,补丁几何中心的纯度可达 93%–96%(FSI 指标下 M1 中心约为 96%,M2 中心约为 93%),距中心 3–3.5 mm 的边缘区降至约 50%,2 倍半径以外的背景区仅为 4%–8%(图 8)。分区统计显示:in 区平均纯度为 67%(d' 指标,M1 为 74%、M2 为 60%;FSI 指标下两猴均值为 76%),near 区为 16.5%,far 区为 6%(图 8、10)。M2 的单单元数据纯度绝对值略低于多单元,但空间衰减范围完全一致(r = 0.78,图 9)。
- 补丁内外选择性分布形态相似但均值与方差分离:各区带的 d' 分布呈现单峰偏态,可用广义极值(GEV)分布拟合:in 区的均值约为 far 区的 2 倍,方差从 far 区的 0.54 增加至 in 区的 1.08(图 11)。强选择性位点(d' ≥ 2)主要集中于补丁内部(占 in 区位点的 24%),far 区未检测到该类位点;模型外推显示补丁内强选择性位点的出现概率约为补丁外的 40 倍。
- 离开补丁中心表现为面孔反应的整体下调:等级排序反应分析(rank-ordered plot)显示,自补丁中心向外延伸时,所有面孔图像诱发的平均放电率系统性降低,而对最优物体图像的反应上升,对非偏好物体的反应基本不变(图 12)。即使在补丁中心,最弱面孔刺激诱发的反应仍略低于最优物体刺激的反应。皮层上层与下层位点的空间组织与纯度剖面无显著差异(图 13、14)。
图注解读
图 1 · 用 fMRI 找到三个面孔补丁
原文图注:Figure 1. fMRI localization of face-selective patches. A, Conventional images of macaque faces and familiar everyday objects used to localize face-selective regions in the temporal lobe. Subsets of these images were also used in the neurophysiology experiments. B, Three fMRI-identified patches were found on the convexity of the lower bank of the STS. C, The MFP was observed consistently across both animals on the convexity of the STS (e.g., crown of the ITG). Only positive valued signal change to the faces-objects contrast is shown and only for voxels that were more significantly driven by the presentation of object images over scrambled versions of those images.
A 为定位所用的猕猴面孔与日常物体图例,B、C 为两只猴 STS 下岸凸面上的激活图。读图要点是 MFP 在两猴上的位置一致(ITG 冠部),且只有对完整图像响应显著强于打乱图像的体素才被计入面孔-物体对比,这保证了后续电生理靶点不是运动伪影或边缘效应。它是整个研究的"靶区定义图"。

图 2 · X 光定位与皮层配准流程
原文图注:Figure 2. Spatial registration and analysis methods. The 3D spatial locations of all sampled sites in the MFP region were estimated with a custom-built stereoscopic x-ray imaging system. The 3D locations were registered (A, left) to a high-resolution (500 μm) anatomical MRI. Anatomical variability before (gray cortical ribbon; left, inset) and after neurophysiological recordings (blue cortical ribbon, left inset) can result in subpixel registration error. To improve the overall accuracy of the registration, nonlinear registration using FMRIB's FNIRT registration tool was performed (A, right), and the resulting transform was applied to the estimated positions of the recording sites (A, inset represents the overall spatial movement of sites projected in a 2D slice)…
这张方法图说明位点坐标如何获得:双 X 光源重建电极尖端三维位置 → 与颅架参考体积配准 → 经 FLIRT 线性 + FNIRT 非线性配准到解剖 MRI → 投影到皮层中层面网格,位移超过 1250 μm 的位点剔除;分析区是以 fMRI MFP 中心为圆心、测地半径 7 mm 的展平区域(避免并入后部 PL 或前部 AL 补丁)。读图时重点理解"为什么这套流程能把定位误差压到亚毫米"——这是全文所有空间结论可信度的根基。

图 3 · 展平皮层上的面孔偏好位点分布
原文图注:Figure 3. pMFP contains an enrichment of face-preferring sites. A, Flattened 2D regions of the temporal lobe highlight category preference. Red represents sites that prefer faces over objects. Blue represents sites that prefer objects over faces. M1, n = 425; M2, n = 565 multiunit sites. The size of each circle represents the strength of selectivity at each site. B, Distribution of highly category-selective sites. Red or blue sites responded preferentially to faces (d' ≥ 0.65) or objects (d' ≤ −0.65), respectively. Yellow represents sites where the 95% CI of the site's selectivity metric fell within [−0.65, 0.65] and thus is not significantly above (or below) those two thresholds. Scale bars represent 1 mm.
A 图把每个位点画成展平皮层上的一个圆:红=偏好面孔、蓝=偏好物体、圆的大小=选择性强度;B 图只画高选择性位点(|d'|≥0.65,黄点表示 95% 置信区间未越过阈值)。读图要点:红色位点富集成带、位于 ITG 冠部,但带内混有蓝点与不同大小的红点——这就是"富集但异质"的直观形态,支撑主要结果 1 与 3。

图 4 · 三种空间模型的拟合与径向剖面
原文图注:Figure 4. 2D models of the spatial organization of face selectivity on the pMFP. Three models (rows: box car, isotropic Gaussian, and anisotropic Gaussian) for the spatial structure of the pMFP were used to fit the category selectivity and 2D spatial position over all multiunit samples. Column 1 summarizes each model and their 2D spatial parameters (see Materials and Methods). Column 2 (monkey 1) and column 3 (monkey 2) summarize the results in each subject. The best fit models are displayed as outlines on the flattened 2D cortical maps (left) with the estimated size parameter for each model type underneath. In addition, the collapsed, 1D selectivity profiles (right) as a function of radial distance are shown (black dots represent individual sites), and the collapsed model prediction is overlaid in red…
行自上而下为盒车、各向同性高斯、各向异性高斯模型,各列给出拟合轮廓线与其尺寸参数(直径 5.96/6.50 mm;FWHM 5.70/7.10 mm;4.45×2.55 / 4.10×2.20 mm);右侧一维径向剖面中黑点为位点实测 d'、红线为模型预测。读图时既看轮廓大小(约 6 mm 的核心结论),也看黑点对红线的偏离——模型只解释了约三分之一方差,为"补丁内有高频结构"埋下伏笔。支撑主要结果 2。

图 5 · 不同模型给出一致的补丁中心与范围
原文图注:Figure 5. Low-frequency 2D spatial models of the pMFP are largely consistent. The spatial location and category preference for each recording site are localized on 2D flattened surfaces of the fMRI-identified MFP region. The different best fit models from our analysis are largely consistent in their estimate of the center and the spatial extent of the enriched region. Scale bars represent 1 mm.
这张图把三种模型各自的最优轮廓叠在同一张展平皮层上:中心位置与空间范围彼此吻合。它的作用是稳健性检查——"约 6 mm 直径"不是某个特定模型的产物,而是低频结构本身的属性。支撑主要结果 2 的尺寸估计。

图 6 · 邻近位点间选择性的真实差异
原文图注:Figure 6. Variance in selectivity estimated at nearby spatial locations in the MFP. Bargraph represents the average squared difference in face selectivity between sites recorded on the same electrode and ±500 μm apart from each other. The average difference between sites expected simply from the use of a limited number of image exemplars or trials is also depicted for comparison. Error bars indicate the 95% CI on the estimate. Black and gray bars represent Subjects 1 and 2, respectively.
柱高为同一次穿透内相距 ≤500 μm 的位点对之间 d' 差的平方均值(黑=M1、灰=M2),并与仅由重复次数、图像抽样造成的期望变异对照。实测柱远高于两个期望柱,说明邻近位点的面孔偏好差异是真实的神经差异而非测量噪声。这张图是主要结果 3 的定量证据,也是否定均匀模块假说的关键。

图 7 · d' 与 FSI 两套指标的换算
原文图注:Figure 7. Direct comparison of d' and FSI contrast metrics. Absolute values of d' depend critically on how one defines response variance (see Materials and Methods). The FSI metric displays an approximately linear relationship to selectivity measured with d'. In our data, an FSI ≥ 1/3 is equivalent to a range of d' values with a median of 0.65. Most of these sites with a d' ≥ 0.65 have a face image preference significantly different from zero (422 of 424 sites with d' ≥ 0.65 had a bootstrapped 95% CI ≥ 0).
横轴 FSI、纵轴 d',二者近似线性;FSI=1/3("面孔响应两倍于物体"的经典标准)对应的 d' 中位数是 0.65,这解释了后文阈值 d'≥0.65 的来源,且绝大多数达标位点的选择性经 bootstrap 检验显著非零。这张图保证纯度结论不依赖于选哪套指标。

图 8 · 纯度随离补丁中心距离衰减
原文图注:Figure 8. Functional selectivity and purity estimates in the pMFP as a function of spatial size. Estimates of the fraction of category-selective multiunit sites in the MFP (the purity) could range from 94% to 58% depending on the distance from the center of the patch. These ranges varied due to both the model and metric used to define the patch. Purity estimates based on an FSI ≤ 0.33 led to higher overall purity estimates than those based on a comparable d'. Overall, the purity falls off gradually from the center of the patch to cortical regions outside the patch. Dotted lines indicate the radial average distance from the center, which defines the qualitative distance categories: "in," "near," and "far"…
横轴为到补丁中心的径向距离(点线标出 in/near/far 的分界,即按盒车半径的 1 倍与 2 倍),纵轴为面孔选择性位点比例(纯度),不同曲线对应不同的模型×指标组合。读图要点:所有曲线都从中心高位单调滑落——中心最高约 96%(FSI 口径)/约 78%(d' 口径、多单元),外围约 50%,远处背景 4%–8%;in/near/far 三区带纯度分别平均 67%/16.5%/6%(d' 口径)。这是全文核心结果图,支撑主要结果 4。

图 9 · 单单元与多单元的纯度剖面一致
原文图注:Figure 9. Comparison between single-unit and multiunit purity estimates in the pMFP as a function of spatial size. Spike waveforms from Subject M2 were sorted to provide SUA. Using the center of the isotropic Gaussian model fit to the MUA data, we plotted the fraction of face-selective sites (purity) for both MUA (gray line) and SUA (black line) as a function of distance from the center. In both cases, a site was defined as face-selective if its d' was ≥ 0.65. Both MUA and SUA produced a gradual fall-off in purity over a similar spatial range, although MUA data showed slightly higher d' values and thus slightly higher purity estimates…
用 M2 的 288 个单单元(SUA)与同一数据的多单元(MUA)分别计算纯度随距离的剖面(1 mm 滑动窗、最少 5 个位点;d'≥0.65 标准)。两条线都在相同的空间范围内渐降,说明梯度结构不是多单元信号混合的伪影;MUA 的 d' 略高、纯度略高也如实注明。支撑主要结果 4 的稳健性。

图 10 · 跨动物合并的平均纯度剖面
原文图注:Figure 10. Average spatial profile of the number of face-selective sites in the pMFP. We estimated the purity collapsed across both animals using the estimated center from the isotropic Gaussian spatial model. The empirical purity function across both animals is remarkably consistent in shape across different selectivity estimators. The plot represents the proportion of face-selective sites across both animals under various criteria for face selectivity. Not surprisingly, weaker thresholds resulted in higher estimates of the purity near the center and far outside the pMFP.
把两猴位点按各向同性高斯模型的中心合并计算纯度剖面,多组面孔选择性阈值各给一条曲线。形状高度一致、只是阈值越松整体越高,说明"中心富集、向外衰减"的形状对判据选择不敏感。与图 8 相互印证,支撑主要结果 4。

图 11 · 补丁内外面孔选择性分布的比较
原文图注:Figure 11. Distributions of face selectivity inside and outside of the pMFP. A, Distributions of the estimated face selectivity from multiunit samples in and out of the pMFP have similar distributional forms but are mean shifted and differ in their variability. B, Units outside the pMFP (light gray) appear to occupy a relatively narrow range of category-selective values (at least for this image set), with the majority of values near zero, whereas sites in the pMFP (black) are characterized by a broad range of selectivity and extreme positive values.
A 图比较 in、near、far 三区带的 d' 分布(GEV 拟合参数:均值 μ=0.69/0.48/0.52,标准差 σ=1.08/0.78/0.54),三者的分布形状相似但均值与宽度不同;B 图叠加显示补丁外分布窄、集中在零附近,补丁内分布宽、长尾延伸到极端正值(24% 的位点 d'≥2,far 区为零,按外推补丁内强选择性位点富集约 40 倍)。这张图把"补丁=分布整体右移并加宽"的定量刻画交给读者,支撑主要结果 5。

图 12 · 补丁内外的图像排名-响应曲线
原文图注:Figure 12. Selectivity across face and object images inside and outside the pMFP. Site-by-site image responses were normalized by the site's maximum absolute response across all images and then ranked using independent data (within face or nonface image groupings; see Materials and Methods) before averaging over all sites and both monkey subjects in each of the three anatomical regions described previously ("In," "Near," and "far"; based on distances of 1 and 2 SDs of the fit isotropic Gaussian model). The responses to all face (black curves) and nonface objects (blue) are shown for sites in the "in," "near," and "far" regions. In the pMFP, the best driving face image gave a greater response than the best driving object exemplar; and outside the pMFP (middle and right panels), the response to the best driving face image was far exceeded by the response to the best driving object exemplar. To prevent any bias, images were rank-ordered on a held-out set of trials, and the remaining trials were used for plotting rank-ordered responses.
横轴为图像排名(黑=面孔、蓝=物体,各自组内从最响到最不响),纵轴为归一化响应。读图要点:in 区的最佳面孔图像响应高于最佳物体图像;near/far 区反过来,最佳物体远超最佳面孔;且远离中心时是全部面孔响应走低、只有最佳物体响应升高。这排除了"补丁外仍有少数面孔专家细胞支撑高响应"的稀疏化解释,支撑主要结果 6。

图 13 · 上层与下层位点的空间分布
原文图注:Figure 13. Upper and lower regions of the cortical ribbon show similar selectivity profiles. Dividing sites that could be reliably (see Materials and Methods) localized in the "upper" or "lower" layers did not reveal additional spatial structure. For comparison, sites localized to within 1 mm of the middle of the cortical ribbon were used to create a "middle layer." These sites could overlap upper and lower layer sites. A, Monkey 1. B, Monkey 2. Scale bars represent 1 mm.
把可信定位到位点按皮层带上层(软膜下 500 μm)与下层(白膜上 500 μm)分开重新画在展平皮层上(另设可重叠的"中层"作对照)。读图要点:两层都呈现同样的中心富集形态,没有发现随深度变化的额外空间结构。它是二维假设(面孔选择性沿皮层切向变化)的 3D 检验,支撑主要结果 6 的层间结论。

图 14 · 上、中、下层的平均选择性比较
原文图注:Figure 14. Face selectivity estimates for upper, lower, and middle cortical layers. Separating sites by upper and lower layers produces similar selectivity estimates of the average selectivity in the "in," "near," and "far" regions (black, dark gray, and light gray bars, respectively), in either subject (A: Monkey 1; B: Monkey 2).
A、B 分别为两猴:横轴 in/near/far 三区带,黑、深灰、浅灰柱分别为上、中、下层位点的平均面孔选择性。各层的柱形走势一致(in 最高、向外降低),说明面孔偏好的径向梯度在层间近似成立,没有明显的层特异性组织。支撑主要结果 6 与讨论中"二维建模假设成立"的辩护。

讨论
作者将既往文献在纯度估计上的分歧(Tsao 等 2006 报道近 97%,而 Bell 等 2011 报道约 42%)归结为采样位置偏差与空间定位不确定性:仅采样补丁中心易得出极高纯度(FSI ≥ 0.33 标准下中心可达 93%–96%),偏向边缘则纯度明显偏低,两者反映了同一连续渐变空间剖面的不同区段。这表明不存在全由面孔神经元构成的离散均一结构,MFP 本质上是由中心峰向外单调衰减的富集区,且补丁内部存在宏观模型(解释约 1/3 方差)未涵盖的局部精细结构。在机制层面,作者提出两种互补解释:一是高频结构可能对应真实世界图像特征的连续拓扑地图(如光学成像观察到的视角模块聚类,Tanaka 等 1991;Wang 等 1996/1998);二是多层级网络在优化面孔识别任务时自然涌现的表征多样性(Yamins 等 2014 的分布式编码观点),这与补丁中心最弱面孔刺激的放电率仍低于最优物体刺激的现象相一致。
作者亦指出了本研究的方法学局限:测试图像库规模较小(10 张正脸图像);d' 依赖方差的统计定义,纯度绝对值受判据标准影响(在 FSI 标准下补丁外背景仍有约 10% 位点符合选择性定义);垂直于皮层深度的定位误差与组织形变限制了层构筑分析的精度;此外,微电极记录主要反映相关性神经表征,因果功能仍有待结合群体光遗传抑制等干预手段进一步验证。关于测得的 6 mm 补丁直径大于既往光形成像所见的 ~1 mm 功能柱,作者解释为记录区域更偏后侧、电生理采样跨度更大,以及面孔与物体的宽泛分类对比产生了更高的信号对比度。
一句话总结
该研究表明猕猴下颞叶中央面孔补丁是一个直径约 6 mm、纯度由中心 90% 以上向外单调衰减的空间富集区,其内部存在真实的微尺度异质性,否定了均一离散的功能模块假说。