该研究通过清醒猕猴单细胞记录探讨了视觉工作记忆(visual working memory, VWM)中下颞叶皮层(inferior temporal cortex, ITC)的功能定位:检验 ITC 仅承担感觉特征编码,还是同时参与记忆保持与刺激匹配比较。实验训练两只猕猴执行四种包含遮挡与干扰条件的“同/不同”辨别任务,记录高选择性 ITC 神经元。结果表明约半数神经元在延迟期维持刺激选择性放电,神经元群体活动足以解码出行为水平的表现,且匹配增强效应在时序上早于局部场电位出现,为 ITC 参与主动工作记忆表征提供了电生理证据。
研究背景
视觉工作记忆是指在外界物理刺激消失后,短时维持、操作与监控视觉表征的能力(Baddeley, 1996)。关于其神经环路,前额叶皮层(prefrontal cortex, PFC)与后部视觉皮层(包括 ITC)的具体分工长期存在争论。早期电生理证据显示,ITC 神经元的选择性延迟期活动易受任务间隔期呈现的无关刺激干扰(Miller et al., 1993),而 PFC 神经元表现出较强的抗干扰能力(Miller et al., 1996)。据此形成的理论模型认为,具体的感觉表征存储于后部皮层,依赖 PFC 自上而下的投射维持其活性(Ranganath and D'Esposito, 2005)。
在此理论框架下,皮层损毁实验提示 ITC 损伤会损害视觉记忆保持(Mishkin, 1982),延迟反应任务中 ITC 神经元也可观察到具备刺激特异性的持续放电(Fuster and Jervey, 1982; Miyashita and Chang, 1988)。此外,Meyers 等(2008)的研究发现 ITC 神经元群体在延迟期末段重新涌现出类别选择性,提示其参与超越了单纯的感觉输入阶段。在匹配比较环节,部分 ITC 神经元对与当前记忆样本匹配的刺激放电升高(匹配增强,match enhancement),对单纯重复的刺激放电降低(匹配抑制,match suppression)(Baylis and Rolls, 1987; Miller and Desimone, 1994)。这种匹配增强机制通常被假定源于 PFC 的自上而下调制,但其确切起源与发生时序尚不明确。此外,以往任务中物体消失的方式与现实环境中的物理遮挡存在差异,有必要在更接近自然遮挡的条件下检验高选择性 ITC 神经元在工作记忆各阶段的动态响应。
研究思路
实验设计主要包含三个层面:第一,针对高选择性神经元进行靶向记录。依据前期研究关于高选择性细胞可能优先参与工作记忆保持的提示(Mikami, 1995),实验在在线记录时筛选对特定有效/无效刺激具有高辨别力的神经元,依据刺激选择性指数、ROC 曲线下面积及记录稳定性标准进行严格纳入,以便在单个神经元水平定量分析记忆动态。第二,设计模拟物理遮挡的行为范式。设置了四种延迟期视觉条件:标准刺激消失(空白延迟)、背景色隐形方块渐进遮挡、持续可见黑方块遮挡(提供物理在场线索)以及黑方块内嵌复杂图像遮挡(同时引入在场线索与视觉干扰),用以系统检验外界遮挡形式与干扰刺激对延迟期选择性放电的影响。第三,结合单神经元分析、群体解码与局部场电位时序比对。在单细胞 ROC 指标外,采用线性支持向量机(SVM)解码 64 个神经元的群体信息量,利用韦布尔函数拟合达到行为正确率所需的神经元规模;同时将单神经元放电差分与局部场电位(LFP)差分的发生时序进行高精度对照,若单细胞匹配效应显著早于局部场电位,则提示匹配计算可能起源于 ITC 局部网络,而非由外部投射被动灌入。
方法
实验对象为两只成年雄性恒河猴(M 与 R,体重 9.0–11.0 kg),颅内植入钛质记录小室(Horsley-Clarke 坐标约前 +15 mm、侧 +20 mm),记录位点位于下颞叶皮层(猴 R 经结构 MRI 确证)。使用钨丝微电极(阻抗 1.0–1.5 MΩ 或 7.0 MΩ)记录神经信号,分为低频 LFP(0.3–300 Hz,采样率 2.5 kHz)与高频动作电位(100 Hz–6 kHz,采样率 34 kHz)两路,离线聚类完成单单元分离(Quiroga et al., 2004)。使用 EyeLink II(500 Hz)监控眼位,试次要求注视点维持在 2.5°×2.5° 窗口内。刺激库包含 125 张日常物体彩色图像(2.0°×2.0°,Hemera 图库);记录时对每个神经元固定选用 7 张图像:2 张为预选的有效/无效刺激,5 张为随机图像(其中 1 张用于复杂遮挡)。记录前后各插入一组被动注视任务(viewing-only task,每张图像呈现 200 ms,间隔 200 ms,重复 10 次)以定量标定神经元选择性。
行为任务包含四种“同/不同”判断条件:消失条件(disappear,样本呈现 1 s,空白延迟 1 s,随后呈现选择刺激)、隐形遮挡条件(invisible occluder,背景色方块以 4°/s 匀速下移遮挡样本,延迟期开始时完全遮蔽)、方块遮挡条件(square occluder,黑色方块持续可见至延迟期结束)及复杂遮挡条件(complex occluder,黑色方块内包含复杂图像)。每组包含 96 次测试,四条件均衡分布,有效与无效样本各半,匹配与非匹配试次各半。在记录的 134 个单神经元中,最终纳入 79 个符合质量标准的单元:被动注视中刺激选择性指数 SSI ≥ 0.25(均值 0.70)、ROC 曲线下面积 AUC ≥ 0.75(均值 0.98),且实验前后对 7 张图像的调谐稳定性皮尔逊相关系数 r ≥ 0.75(均值 0.94)。动作电位序列以 σ = 10 ms 高斯核平滑生成放电密度函数(spike density function, SDF)。统计显著性判定采用 Blair-Karniski 置换检验(10,000 次置换,双侧 α = 0.05)。群体 SVM 分类采用线性核函数,每个时间点随机抽取 64 个神经元各 12 次试次进行交叉验证训练与测试,重复重采样 100 次计算解码准确率;针对延迟期后 750 ms 采用韦布尔函数拟合分类正确率随神经元数量(1–64)的变化曲线:正确率 = 1 − 0.5·e^(−(n/τ)^β)。
主要结果
-
编码期具有高选择性,约半数细胞在延迟期维持刺激特异性。 在单细胞水平,典型神经元在四种条件的编码期 AUC 均接近 1.0;在延迟期,部分神经元在包括复杂遮挡在内的所有条件下均保持显著选择性,部分神经元在消失与隐形遮挡条件下于延迟期末段出现选择性回升,而在方块与复杂遮挡条件下放电接近随机水平(图 3)。全群体统计(延迟期后 750 ms)显示:消失、隐形遮挡与方块遮挡的群体平均 AUC 分别为 0.65、0.64 与 0.59(均 p < 0.0001),复杂遮挡条件为 0.52(p = 0.24);具有显著延迟期选择性的细胞比例在消失和隐形遮挡条件下达 41.8%(33/79)与 45.6%(36/79),在复杂遮挡条件下仍有 12.7%(10/79,二项检验 p = 0.006)显著高于随机概率(图 4)。将后 750 ms 分段比较发现,前三种简单条件下神经元 AUC 随时间递增(ΔAUC 分别为 0.05、0.06、0.08,p ≤ 0.0003),表明延迟期后期的选择性并非单纯的感觉衰减残留,而伴随向决策时刻临近的主动重激活(reinstatement)。
-
群体解码准确率显著高于单细胞,约 100 个神经元即可达到动物的行为表现。 滑动窗线性 SVM(64 神经元)在编码期所有条件下均实现近乎完美的分类,且在消失和隐形遮挡的延迟期全程维持显著信息量,准确率在延迟期末段呈上升趋势(图 5A)。针对延迟期后段的整体放电,64 细胞解码正确率在四种条件下分别为 0.995±0.013、0.994±0.016、0.914±0.065 与 0.803±0.088;韦布尔拟合表明达到 82% 准确率所需的神经元参数 τ 分别约为 8.4、9.2、26.7 与 71.3;当外推至 100 个细胞时,预测正确率(1.00、1.00、0.95、0.86)与动物的实际平均行为水平(0.98、0.97、0.96、0.86)高度吻合(图 5B)。
-
选择期响应:ITC 编码选择刺激,其反应潜伏期与行为反应时高度相关。 选择刺激诱发了清晰可分的放电模式;受前向掩蔽效应影响,方块与复杂遮挡条件下的放电起始显著延迟,四种条件下的视觉潜伏期分别约为 117.91、118.63、134.38 与 149.56 ms(F(3,312) = 32.11,p < 0.0001);单细胞视觉潜伏期与动物标准化反应时呈显著正相关(r = 0.66),选择性潜伏期与反应时的相关性更强(r = 0.71,均 p < 0.0001)(图 6)。
-
匹配效应呈现早期增强与晚期抑制的时序分离:早期匹配增强具有刺激特异性,晚期匹配抑制滞后于初始选择性信号。 针对偏好有效刺激,四种条件在视觉反应前 50 ms 内的 AUC 均显著大于 0.5(p ≤ 0.001),后 50 ms 内均显著小于 0.5(p ≤ 0.0014)(图 7C/D);针对无效刺激分析时仅观察到匹配抑制(图 7E),证实早期增强仅特异性作用于编码该刺激的目标细胞群。匹配抑制的平均发生时间比最初的视觉选择性信号延迟 35.37 ms(配对 t 检验 p < 0.0001),表明其并非单纯的早期前馈特性,而反映了后续的信息处理阶段(图 7F)。
-
单细胞动作电位的匹配增强早于局部场电位出现。 匹配与非匹配试次诱发的 LFP 波形在各条件下存在系统差异(图 8A/B),但经过 t 变换时序分析表明,最早达统计显著的匹配差异均出现在单神经元放电序列中,LFP 的匹配差异在时间上显著滞后于放电密度函数的差异(图 8C–F);在隐形遮挡条件下,动作电位的匹配增强在刺激呈现后约 20 ms 即可观测到。此外,延迟期持续放电与匹配增强在机制上表现出一定可分离性:复杂遮挡条件下神经元的持续选择性放电显著减弱,但测试期的匹配增强效应依然存在。
图注解读
图 1 · 任务、刺激与行为表现
原文图注:Figure 1. Task, stimuli, and behavioral performance. A, Disappear condition. A sample was presented for 1 s, followed by a 1 s blank delay period, at the end of which a choice stimulus appeared. The monkey's task was to indicate with either a right or left button press whether the choice matched the sample. B, Invisible occluder condition. Same as in A, except that, during the 1 s sample presentation time, a square of the same color as the background gradually occluded the sample, reaching full occlusion at the onset of the delay interval. C, Square occluder condition. Same as in B, but the occluder was now a black square. D, Complex occluder condition. Same as in C, but there was a complex visual stimulus embedded inside the black square. All conditions (A–D) required the monkey to first fixate a small spot in the center of the display before trial onset. E, Example stimuli. Twelve of the 125 stimuli used throughout the recording sessions. F, Performance of the two monkeys averaged across all recording sessions and sorted by condition. Error bars indicate SD of performance across the 69 sessions. Notice the slightly worse and more variable performance in the complex occluder condition. G, Cumulative distribution of the reaction times of all recording sessions sorted by condition. The more difficult conditions (square and complex occluder) led to longer reaction times (F(3,272) = 180.58; p < 0.0001). (注:原 PDF 提取文本丢失全部空格,此处已按原意复原断词,并因篇幅在后半段略有节选。)
图 A–D 展示了四种行为任务的时序结构:刺激呈现 1 s、延迟间隔 1 s、随后呈现选择刺激,各条件的主要差别在于延迟期间的视觉环境(空白背景、同色方块匀速遮蔽、黑色方块持续呈现、黑色方块内含复杂图案)。图 E 给出 125 个测试图像样本中的 12 个样例。图 F 为两只猕猴在各条件下的辨别正确率均值(误差线代表 69 次测试会话的标准差):前三种简单条件下的正确率约为 90%,复杂遮挡条件下表现略有下降且方差增大。图 G 为反应时的累积分布函数:遮挡难度更高的两个条件反应时显著延长。该图确立了行为任务的操作框架与难度梯度。
图 2 · viewing-only 任务中细胞的选择性
原文图注:Figure 2. Selectivity of cells during a viewing-only task. A, Three typical cells. Each row of plots depicts the responses (rasters and spike density functions) of one cell to the presentation of the effective, ineffective, and complex occluder stimuli as well as to four other randomly chosen objects. Notice the robust selectivity as pertains to the effective and ineffective pair. B, Population averaged spike density functions sorted by effective, ineffective, and complex occluder labels. The plot includes data only from cells that had SSIs ≥ 0.25, AUCs ≥ 0.75, and Pearson's r ≥ 0.75 (for additional details, see Materials and Methods). Note the large and extended differences between the effective and ineffective response time courses. Also, although the complex occluder was chosen randomly, it is evident that it rarely elicited a response much bigger than the ineffective stimulus.
图 A 逐行展示了三个典型神经元的放电点图与放电密度函数(SDF):各子图分别展示其对有效刺激、无效刺激、复杂遮挡物及四张随机刺激的放电反应,显示出对偏好刺激的高度特异性,直观体现了入选标准(SSI ≥ 0.25、AUC ≥ 0.75、稳定性 r ≥ 0.75)的筛选依据。图 B 展示了筛选入组细胞在群体水平的平均 SDF 曲线:有效与无效刺激引起的放电幅度差异显著且持续,而随机分配的复杂遮挡物诱发的反应幅度通常接近无效刺激。该图交代了神经元样本的高选择性特征。
图 3 · 两个示例神经元的编码期与延迟期活动
原文图注:Figure 3. Encoding and delay period activities of two example neurons. A, B, Spike density functions of two example neurons sorted by image effectiveness and condition. Observe the robust response differences during the encoding epoch of all conditions in both A and B. The differences become much smaller during the delay period, vanishing altogether in the square and complex occluder conditions in B. C, D, Sliding window ROC analyses (step, 10 ms; window, 100 ms) for the same two neurons. Each AUC line compares the responses to the effective versus ineffective stimulus for one condition. Note that the neuron in C sustained its stimulus-selective response throughout the delay periods of all conditions. The neuron shown in D, however, exhibited no stimulus selectivity during the delay periods of the square and complex occluder conditions.
图 A 与 B 分别为两个代表性神经元在四种任务条件下对有效与无效刺激的放电密度函数;图 C 与 D 展示了对应神经元的滑动窗 ROC 曲线(步长 10 ms,窗口 100 ms)。两个神经元在编码期均呈现显著的刺激区分度,但延迟期放电出现分化:神经元 C 在全部四种条件下(包括复杂遮挡)在延迟期均维持了显著高于随机水平的 AUC;而神经元 D 在方块遮挡与复杂遮挡下延迟期 AUC 维持在 0.5 附近,仅在消失与隐形遮挡条件下的延迟后期出现选择性回升。该对比呈现了延迟期选择性在不同神经元及任务条件下的具体动态差异。
图 4 · 编码期与延迟期 AUC 的群体分析
原文图注:Figure 4. Analysis of encoding and delay period AUCs. A, AUCs of individual neurons sorted by condition. The plots show the AUCs for all neurons (ordinate) as a function of time (abscissa) and condition (panel). AUC values are color coded, with hotter colors illustrating values closer to 1.0. For every condition independently, we have sorted the neurons in descending order of delay period AUCs (as computed in C). Note, by inspecting the top parts of the panels, that every condition had a subpopulation of neurons that exhibited stimulus-selective responses during the delay. B, Population averaged AUCs. Each curve depicts the sliding window AUCs averaged across the entire population of neurons for one condition. Shaded regions indicate ±1 SEM. The two vertical dotted lines in A and B indicate sample and delay onset, respectively. C, Population histograms of delay period AUCs. The AUC values were computed from the entire last 750 ms of the delay period. The black bars indicate individual cells that were significant at the α = 0.05 level (Mann–Whitney U test). The arrows denote the population means of the distributions. Notice that the population means for the three simpler conditions were all significantly above 0.50 (p < 0.0001 in all cases). Although the complex occluder condition did not have a population mean significantly different from 0.50, 10 individual cells (of 79) did have significantly increased responses to the effective stimulus, more than expected by chance (binomial test, p < 0.006). (注:后半段已节选。)
图 A 为各条件下全部神经元的时序 AUC 热图:纵轴按延迟期 AUC 降序排列神经元,横轴为时间,颜色越红表示 AUC 越接近 1.0,顶部色块展示了具有持续选择性的亚群。图 B 为全群体滑动平均 AUC 变化曲线(阴影代表 ±1 标准误,竖虚线指示样本与延迟起始时刻):样本移除后选择性下降,前三种简单条件在延迟期后段出现规律性回升。图 C 为延迟期后 750 ms 整体 AUC 的频率分布直方图,黑色柱状指示个体差异达显著水平的神经元(Mann-Whitney U 检验),箭头指示群体均值:前三种简单条件的均值显著高于 0.50,复杂遮挡条件下群体均值虽未显著偏离 0.50,但仍有 10 个神经元表现出显著选择性。该图为结果 1 提供了定量统计分布。
图 5 · 线性 SVM 的群体解码分析
原文图注:Figure 5. Population analyses using linear SVM. A, Sliding window SVM analyses. Each panel plots the results of the sliding window SVM analysis (step, 10 ms; window, 100 ms) for one condition. In every case, 64 randomly selected cells were used to train and test the classifier. Shaded regions indicate ±1 SD across 100 bootstrap-like iterations of the training and testing procedure. For every single time point and for every single iteration of the resampling procedure, a new set of 64 randomly selected cells was used. For comparison, we have replotted the average AUC values from Figure 4B (dotted line). Notice the consistently better performance for the population of cells compared with the single cell. Also, note the rise in classification performance as the delay epoch draws to a close. B, Performance of the linear SVM classifier for the entire delay period (1250–2000 ms) as a function of the number of cells and condition. Error bars indicate ±1 SD across 100 bootstrap-like iterations. Lines indicate best-fit Weibull functions. Note the well above chance performance for 64 cells in every single condition (rightmost points). Also, observe that the complex occluder Weibull fit had the highest threshold and shallowest slope, indicating that more cells would be needed to achieve the same level of classifier performance as in the other conditions.
图 A 为基于 64 个随机抽样神经元的滑动窗 SVM 分类准确率时序曲线(阴影为 100 次重抽样的 ±1 标准差,虚线为图 4B 的单细胞平均 AUC 对照):编码期解码率接近 100%,群体解码性能在各阶段均显著高于单细胞指标,并在延迟期末期呈现上升趋势。图 B 展示了延迟期后段(1250–2000 ms)分类准确率随纳入神经元数量(1–64)的变化曲线及韦布尔拟合结果:在 64 细胞规模下,四种条件均显著高于随机水平,复杂遮挡条件的拟合参数具有最高阈值和最平缓斜率。外推分析显示约 100 个神经元即可接近动物的实际行为正确率。
图 6 · 选择期反应分析
原文图注:Figure 6. Analysis of choice epoch responses. A, Population averaged spike density functions sorted by image effectiveness and condition. Note the temporal staggering of the responses reflecting the forward masking effect from the square and complex occluders. B, Population averaged sliding window ROC analyses sorted by condition (step, 10 ms; window, 100 ms). Shaded regions indicate ±1 SEM. The graph confirms the high discriminability of the responses elicited by the effective and ineffective stimuli. C, Scatter plot of the visual latencies of individual cells and the monkey's average standardized reaction times (RTs). Observe the highly significant correlation between the two measures. D, Scatter plot of the selectivity latencies of individual cells and the monkey's average standardized reaction times. Note that the relationship is even stronger than between visual latency and reaction times. In both scatter plots, the colors indicate from which condition the points came and the line is the best least-squares fit to the data.
图 A 为选择阶段各条件下有效与无效刺激诱发的群体平均 SDF 曲线,体现了由于遮挡物前向掩蔽作用导致的放电起始延迟。图 B 为选择期的群体滑动 ROC 曲线,验证了有效与无效刺激的高辨别度。图 C 与 D 分别为单细胞视觉潜伏期与选择性潜伏期对应行为标准化反应时的散点图(直线为最小二乘拟合):选择性潜伏期与行为反应时的相关性(r = 0.71)高于基础视觉潜伏期的相关性(r = 0.66)。该图表明 ITC 神经活动的时序进程与动物辨别决策具有同步性。
图 7 · 单细胞层面的匹配增强与匹配抑制
原文图注:Figure 7. Single-cell match enhancement and suppression effects. A, Population averaged spike density functions sorted by match status and condition, restricted to the effective stimulus. Note the large but delayed match suppression in all conditions. B, Zoomed in view of the spike density functions sorted by match status and condition. This plot reveals a small but reliable match enhancement in all conditions. C, Sliding window ROC analyses comparing match with nonmatch responses (step, 10 ms; window, 100 ms). Values above 0.5 indicate enhancement, whereas values below 0.5 indicate suppression. Shaded regions indicate ±1 SEM. The analysis confirmed an early match enhancement effect that was succeeded by match suppression. D, Match enhancement and suppression as a function of counting window. Shaded regions indicate ±1 SEM. In all conditions, we see a reliable match enhancement that is obscured by match suppression if the integration time is allowed to be long enough. The −log(p value) of Wilcoxon's signed ranks tests done on all data points indicate that indeed both enhancement and suppression were significant [the bottom dashed line indicates −log(0.05)] (for more details, see Results). E, The match enhancement was stimulus specific, because repeating the same analysis outlined in D on the ineffective stimulus yielded only match suppression. F, Scatter plot of match suppression latencies as a function of visual latencies. The dashed line is what would be expected if selectivity and suppression arose simultaneously. Match suppression is unlikely to be purely bottom up because, on average, it was delayed by 35 ms relative to the first sign of visual selectivity (p < 0.0001). Colors denote from which conditions the points came. (注:因篇幅对 D–F 的说明略有节选。)
图 A 展示了偏好有效刺激下按匹配与非匹配分类的群体平均 SDF 曲线,显示反应峰后存在广泛的匹配抑制。图 B 放大了初始时段波形,呈现出早期稳定的匹配增强现象。图 C 为匹配与非匹配的滑动 ROC 曲线(高于 0.5 为增强,低于 0.5 为抑制),证实早期短暂增强后转变为持续抑制。图 D 展示了随积分窗口递增的增强与抑制效应变化:早期约 50 ms 呈现增强,若窗口过长则被随后的抑制所掩盖。图 E 证实对无效刺激仅出现抑制而无增强,说明增强具有刺激特异性。图 F 为匹配抑制潜伏期与视觉反应潜伏期的散点对比,数据点普遍分布于等值线上方,平均滞后约 35 ms。该图完整呈现了匹配增强与抑制的两阶段特征。
图 8 · LFP 匹配效应及其与尖信号效应的关系
原文图注:Figure 8. LFP match effects and their relation to spike match effects. A, Raw LFP waveforms averaged across all stimuli and sessions and sorted by match status and condition. Note the small but reliable differences in the match/nonmatch waveforms. B, LFP difference waveforms (match − nonmatch). Notice the consistent differences across the four conditions. C–F, t-transformed LFP differences (dark lines) and SDF differences (light lines). The times at which the LFP or SDF differences became significant is indicated by the dark or light bars, respectively, at the bottom of the plots. Note that, in all cases, the very first significant match effect was present in the single-cell responses. Also, observe that the LFP differences seem to be lagging the SDF differences.
图 A 为各条件下平均的原始局部场电位波形;图 B 为匹配与非匹配的 LFP 差分曲线(match − nonmatch)。图 C–F 展示了经 t 变换处理的 LFP 差分(深色实线)与单细胞 SDF 差分(浅色实线)的时序对比,底部横条分别指示其达到统计显著的起始时刻:在所有四种条件下,最早的匹配效应均首先在单细胞放电层面达到显著,LFP 的匹配差异在时序上系统性滞后。这一时序先后关系支持了匹配增强效应主要起源于 ITC 局部网络处理的推论。
讨论
作者将实验发现置于“PFC 提供自上而下维持信号、后部感觉皮层持有内容”的理论框架中进行讨论:延迟期选择性放电的回升被解释为与任务相关的视觉记忆表征在 ITC 中的主动重激活。解剖学上丰富的 PFC→ITC 反馈连接(Pandya and Yeterian, 1990)以及 PFC 本身具备的预期性延迟活动(Rainer et al., 1999; Rainer and Miller, 2002)构成了这一重激活信号的可能来源;另一个潜在的反馈来源是内侧邻近的嗅周皮层(perirhinal cortex, PRh)——配对联想学习研究显示检索信号往往先出现于 PRh、随后传递至 ITC(Naya et al., 1996, 2001),且两区域的延迟期选择性主要针对搜索目标维持(Takeda et al., 2005),但由于本任务中样本与目标一致,无法拆分两者的独立贡献。
针对复杂遮挡条件下单细胞持续放电减少的现象,作者提出了三种可能解释:第一,任务难度增加使自上而下的注意维持更受限,此时外部感觉输入竞争抑制了短时记忆表征;第二,根据群体解码结果,行为维持并不完全依赖单个细胞的高频延迟放电,64 个神经元的联合信息已显著优于单细胞,约 100 个细胞即足以支持任务完成;第三,依据计算模型(Mongillo et al., 2008; Sugase-Miyamoto et al., 2008),记忆痕迹可以隐式存储在突触权重的易化中,而在回忆或测试刺激输入时以放电模式重新被激活,这与复杂遮挡条件下“放电水平的选择性减弱、但测试期匹配增强依然存在”的数据特征相契合。
对于匹配增强,作者沿用偏置竞争理论(biased competition,Desimone and Duncan, 1995)将其理解为对任务目标特征的注意偏置;本研究表明这种增强特异性地作用于编码目标刺激的神经元群体,且由于样本的高选择性而更为清晰,同时单细胞放电先于 LFP 发生提示该计算大概率在 ITC 局部形成。针对匹配抑制,其发生时序系统性滞后于初始选择性信号约 35 ms,更符合加工完成与神经易化假说(James et al., 2000; Grill-Spector et al., 2006; Freedman et al., 2006)。总体而言,在结合前额叶或内侧颞叶反馈的调制下,ITC 不仅参与初始视觉编码,也在不可见视觉特征的短时保持与刺激比对中发挥功能。
一句话总结
该研究证实了下颞叶皮层在视觉工作记忆延迟期间保持刺激特异性放电,群体神经活动足以支撑行为辨别水平,且匹配增强效应早于局部场电位出现,表明 ITC 同时承担着感觉特征编码与短时记忆维持的双重功能。